Better Call Saul did the same for Breaking Bad, and many people think it's the better show. Fargo is the other useful model: officially an anthology, but each season quietly connects to the others. Viewers enjoy spotting those connections, and newcomers don't need them. That's your "anthology that isn't really an anthology."
The retro style has more appeal than you might expect, too. "Trials and Tribble-ations" is still one of the most loved episodes in the whole franchise. Younger audiences have also embraced older formats as style choices rather than limitations: vinyl, film cameras, VHS-look video.
What could make it fail. There are three real risks.
- Answering questions no one asked. Solo is the warning. It explained Han's name, his dice and the Kessel Run, gaps fans had never wondered about, and it underperformed. Your list avoids this because the Romulan War, Ceti Alpha V and Kirk's last years are stories fans have discussed for decades. Choosing the right gaps is most of the job.
- Assigned homework. Superhero fatigue came largely from viewers feeling they had to watch everything to follow anything. Each event has to work for someone who has never seen Star Trek. Ceti Alpha V should land as a gripping survival story even if you've never heard of Khan. Recognizing the references should be a bonus, not a requirement.
- Streaming economics. Anthologies lose viewers between installments, because each event starts its audience from zero. Sisko is the answer to that: he gives viewers a reason to come back even when the setting changes completely. That only holds if his segments stay short and pointed, like Serling's. If they bloat, they become something to skip.
My honest verdict. For longtime fans I think it's almost a sure thing. It offers what they've wanted for 30 years, done by people who clearly respect the source. For binge-watchers new to Trek, it works if each event is self-contained and the releases stay infrequent enough to feel like an occasion. The "peek into a wider universe" idea is what Marvel and Star Wars sold, and it wore thin only when it became constant and required viewing. One well-made, optional event a year is the way to keep it working.
I think you're right, and K-7 might be the most natural spinoff hiding in the original series. "The Trouble with Tribbles" (1967) quietly set up everything a station series needs: a space station run jointly by civilians and Starfleet, sitting in contested territory, with Klingons and Starfleet officers sharing a bar, a shady trader in Cyrano Jones, a Klingon spy in Arne Darvin, and a Federation bureaucrat in Nilz Baris fighting over Sherman's Planet. That's DS9's whole cast list, 26 years early.
It's a Cold War show
What makes K-7 especially right for the retro strand is its era. In 1967, the station is essentially Berlin. The Organian Peace Treaty forces the Federation and the Klingons into a cold peace, with outside referees and strict rules. Whichever side develops Sherman's Planet most efficiently wins it, so the competition is fought with grain shipments, colonists and spies instead of starships. That's a 1960s spy drama, The Spy Who Came in from the Cold in space, and it would be shot in the exact style of the original series.
The continuity people get a bonus, too. The 1967 look means smooth-foreheaded Klingons, and since Enterprise explained that appearance through the Augment virus, the retro style is also canonically correct. No one has to say a word about it.
How it explains DS9
You've put your finger on a real gap. In 2369, Starfleet takes over Terok Nor, a Cardassian station orbiting Bajor, a world that isn't a Federation member. Someone had to work out the legal basis for that long before.
K-7 is where the precedent comes from. Sherman's Planet isn't Federation territory. It's disputed ground under the Organian treaty, so K-7 is a Federation installation operating outside Federation sovereignty, run jointly by a civilian station manager (Mr. Lurry in the episode) and Starfleet. Over the series, the station's staff improvise the rules that make that work:
- The host keeps sovereignty. The Federation operates there by invitation or treaty, not ownership.
- Civilians and Starfleet share command. That's the model for Sisko working alongside Bajor's government and militia.
- The station stays open to everyone. Traders, rival powers and non-members can all use it, which is why a Ferengi bar on DS9 is perfectly legal.
- "Deep Space" becomes a doctrine, not just a naming convention: a class of stations for frontier diplomacy.
In-universe, these could be called the K-7 Protocols. When Bajor's provisional government asks the Federation to administer its station in 2369, the legal framework has existed for a century. Sisko's job is the K-7 station commander's job, inherited.
Other questions it could answer
- Where did the Organians go? They imposed peace in "Errand of Mercy," yet they never stop the later Klingon conflicts. A K-7 series could show them stepping back once both sides prove they can keep the peace themselves, a coming-of-age story for the Federation and the Klingon Empire alike. It ends where The Undiscovered Country's Khitomer Accords begin.
- How did Klingons and Starfleet learn to share space? The bar on K-7 is where that history starts, long before Worf.
- Where do traders like Quark come from? Cyrano Jones is the original frontier opportunist living in the cracks of a treaty, and the station needs him as much as it resents him.
Where it fits in the timeline
There's an open slot in December 2017, exactly 50 years after "The Trouble with Tribbles" aired. K-7 could be the first retro event to become a recurring series: 13 episodes in full 1967 style, with a second season if it connects.
The Witness framing is already built in, because Sisko has literally been there. In "Trials and Tribble-ations," he and Dax went back to K-7 and he met Kirk. His opening segment practically writes itself: "I stood on this station once, for an afternoon. I shook James Kirk's hand. I never asked who built the place, or why it was there. I should have."
Of everything we've sketched tonight, this one has the strongest case. It fills a gap people actually wonder about, it works for newcomers as a stand-alone Cold War drama, and it makes the show fans already love, DS9, mean more in hindsight.
Chapters you can skip, but probably won't want to
You've described what makes the format work socially. Each event is optional for understanding the main series but essential for the conversation. You can follow Pathfinder without ever watching The Lost Logs. But when everyone online is arguing about Janeway's briefing-room decision, you'll want to be in on it, and that pull matters more than any obligation.
There's a release-strategy question in that. Dropping all episodes at once on a Friday gives you a spoiler weekend and then silence. Weekly releases keep people talking for a month or two, which is why Andor and The White Lotus dominated conversation the way they did. A hybrid probably fits the Witness events best: the first two or three chapters at once to hook binge-watchers, then one a week so the shared conversation builds toward the finale.
The ending is fixed, like the last chapter of a book whose final page you've already read. Because everyone knows where it lands, the shared suspense is about how it gets there, and that gives everyone something to talk about.